OLD FASHION CREAM PIE

$4.00

Taxes included. Shipping calculated at checkout.

A childhood classic, all grown up. Two soft, cinnamon-kissed oatmeal cookies sandwich a generous swirl of fluffy vanilla cream for the perfect blend of chewy, creamy, and cozy. Made with old-fashioned oats and a hint of brown sugar, it’s a treat that feels homemade—because it is. Comfort food never tasted so sweet.

FAQ

Yes, we offer gluten-free options and take extra care to clean our equipment to reduce cross-contamination. However, we do handle common allergens like wheat, dairy, eggs, nuts, and soy, so we can’t guarantee products are allergen-free.

Our kitchen handles common allergens like dairy, eggs, wheat, nuts, and soy. While we offer some nut-free options, we cannot guarantee allergen-free products due to shared equipment.

We are a home bakery located in Buckeye, Az

While we are working on all of our products, the great news is.... We do ship cookies anywhere in the U.S. Every order is carefully packed to preserve freshness and arrive in perfect condition.

Yes! We offer local pickup options for customers near Buckeye AZ. You’ll receive a message with pickup instructions once your order is confirmed.

Orders are typically baked and shipped every Tuesday. You’ll receive a tracking number once your package is on its way.

Because our products are made fresh to order, we do not offer refunds. However, if there’s an issue with your order, please contact us within 48 hours and we’ll be happy to offer store credit when appropriate.

OLD FASHION CREAM PIE

You may also like

SUBSCRIBE

FAQ

We are a home bakery located in Buckeye, Az

Contact us